Review – Sparrow Hill Road

Sparrow Hill Road (Ghost Stories No.1) – Seanan McGuire

DAW Books, 2014

Rose Marshall died in the summer of 1952 when her car was driven off Sparrow Hill Road, and that was only the beginning of her problems. Rose is a hitcher now, a ghost of the roads, and the rules that she doesn’t live by are as unforgiving as they are arcane. Over the years she has become a story – the Phantom Prom Date, the Girl in the Green Silk Gown – and sometimes stories draw the wrong sort of attention. From rookie ghost-hunters to drivers on their last hope, her fellow unquiet dead to the vengeful living, Rose has more to fear now than she ever did when she was alive. Worst of all is the man who killed her that night on Sparrow Hill Road. Given the chance, he is going to finish the job, and there are much worse things than death.

Sparrow Hill Road is written as if it was once a collection of ghost stories, a bit non-linear, which conveys Rose’s experience of the world incredibly well. I loved it. The layered mythology, from modern American ghost stories all the way down to Hades and Persephone, creates a complete and fascinating world, and Rose, with her good heart and bad attitude, is a marvelously flawed protagonist. I’m very much looking forward to reading more in this series.

Review No.233 – Her Fearful Symmetry

Her Fearful Symmetry – Audrey Niffenegger

Jonathan Cape, 2009

The Poole twins exist in a world of two. When a letter arrives announcing the death of an aunt they did not know they had, who has left them everything she had, they are startled to realise their mother is a twin too – and that twenty years ago something so terrible happened between the sisters that they never saw each other again. Even after her death, Elspeth has not let go of the grievance. If the twins want to keep their legacy, they must leave America and come to live in her London flat for one year. Meanwhile, in England, Elspeth’s lover Robert is struggling to accept her death – and so, for that matter, is Elspeth…

Having enjoyed Niffenegger’s first novel earlier this year, I wanted to read more of her work. The same beautiful language, attention to detail and quietly melancholic atmosphere are all present, but where The Time Traveler’s Wife was tightly plotted with good momentum, Her Fearful Symmetry is much slower to get off the ground. What could have been a very effective modern ghost story comes apart in the second half, depending as it does on bizarre contrivances, and I was left bewildered by the ending. I also think it would make for a frustrating read if you are a twin.